NGC3079 P1 Freeze Report

XMM-Newton Wind Decomposition — Phase 1 Executable Gates
P1 FROZEN 17/17 Tasks ACCEPTED 1900 Tests Passed V5 Immutable
17
P1 Tasks Complete
1900
Total Tests Passed
0
Critical Findings
153/153
V5 Snapshot Intact

Verification Summary

CheckResult
Full P1 test suite1900 passed
Predecessor freeze tests35 passed
Firewall V6 probe80 PASS
D025 delta probe26 PASS
V3 governance probe50 PASS
Ruff lintAll checks passed
V5 snapshot validator153/153 OK
Residue scan0

Review History Summary

10 Clean passes
(0C/0I/0M)
7 Passes with
nonblocking findings
3 REQUEST_CHANGES
→ surgical fix → re-review PASS
0 Critical
findings
4 Total Important
(all fixed)
22 Total Minor
(all nonblocking)

All 17 P1 Tasks

# Gate Module Tests Review C/I/M Module SHA-256 Test SHA-256
1public_manifest312Spec v6 + CQ v30/0/073d5dd17…824345f1cb1e6…0d76b
2ids164Spec + Quality0/0/1Mdf318d70…1c8d909855be4…0f35b
3bundle30Spec + Quality0/0/8Mf3163822…9ef49c662cb79…bcd8d
4strict_npz28Combined0/0/5Mc8c457e2…be310c5bae38c…cbeda
5d4457RC→fix→re-review0/0/041fead1b…72315fadef61d…53f84
6splits83RC→fix→re-review0/0/00153bad0…44718cfd810dd…e9be6
7candidate_output124Combined0/0/2Mee62f9a7…1a3055f20487a…cb30a
8output_gates84Combined0/0/2M7927efd5…53b7988f5d2ba…042ea
9uncertainty75Combined0/1/4Mbbcb35cc…5759a1255068…9556
10scorer55Combined0/0/059bb5db3…070617a30cf9…82c0
11adapter57Combined0/0/04056bc59…5876e3199e26…50d4
12runtime63Combined0/0/024b0b7e4…6f4270a612e71…925a
13response_inventory50RC→fix→re-review0/0/02aea1a98…0c32ef8f4d8e9…3139
14ogip_export72Combined0/0/04a3ecf89…6c12773cd19fd…1fe9
15basis_provenance51RC→fix×2→re-review×20/0/0cbcb2edc…6e45e5fb6b940…c9251
16identifiability115Combined0/0/06ebed754…87fec98765d8…ebb3
17power_pilot80Combined0/0/0777f301d…194b57365c73…2d6d

P0 Immutable Reference

FieldValue
SnapshotP0_FIXED_POINT_V5_20260715T215301Z
Promotion DecisionD028
V5 METADATA_SHA2562753f70d132b5606470ea8bc6466cbbdeab6ba0dbe5d49c4df70c118714a7e62
V5 LEDGER_SHA2568076c22dd4b25fa490b6bbd068ed87977b972e1498b5cbed99ccac23c38e8119
V5 MANIFEST_SHA2563904ce5e8bc61842b4786cd5c9e3221937e2955e1ed1ef84b450eb9471ab2cb2
Files154 files / 23 dirs / 151 payload / 153 ledger

Benchmark Contract Pins

ContractSHA-256
DISCOVERY_FIREWALL_V1_DRAFT.jsona7ffa08d268beb4e271b0014bc30dbc09a7b5b870c5d791168d8520de3021ef2
PUBLIC_INPUT_SCHEMA_V1_DRAFT.json2c66271fd56f1bf2f7da1fc2016c70ad20e31c6f8a184ae15bed28c63438ac27
CANDIDATE_OUTPUT_LAYOUT_V1_DRAFT.json3b5f5fdbe78c56c863b438919dc3eae8ec5b8af02e8c9c91035648ebbd50844b

Methodology

Strict TDD

Every task followed RED → GREEN → review cycle. Tests written first, then minimal implementation, then combined spec+quality review by independent subagent.

Review Process

Each task received a combined spec+quality review. Findings classified as Critical (blocking), Important (must fix), or Minor (nonblocking). REQUEST_CHANGES triggered surgical TDD fix → re-review until PASS.

Privacy Enforcement

All gates enforce closed-schema with no private data leakage. Private fields (obs_id, exp_id, filter, exposure_tag, event_sha256) are rejected in public output. Only HMAC-derived public asset IDs are exposed.

V5 Immutability

P0 V5 snapshot remains immutable throughout P1. All 153 ledger records verified intact after every task. No residue, no bytecode.